Learning explanations
Contributions, attribution, and evidence · Answer key
1. Read a patent claim precisely.
He alone invented all electric lighting.: That exceeds the scope of a particular process patent.
The patent proves his family lineage.: Patent attribution and genealogical relationships are different claims.
He patented a particular manufacturing improvement.: This matches the documented scope without erasing other inventors.
Source: Bringing light for all
2. Distinguish biography from artwork evidence.
An unrelated painting chosen for decoration.: A substitute image cannot document the work being discussed.
The work itself and its museum catalog record.: These allow examination of the specific object, attribution, and context.
An uncited claim that it was the world’s first.: A superlative needs evidence beyond a general biography.
Source: Henry Ossawa Tanner
3. Distinguish a responsibility from a formal title.
Preserve the separate dates and roles.: The distinction avoids assigning a later formal title too early.
Replace both with one guessed date.: Guessing discards the documented chronology.
Treat the two descriptions as interchangeable.: Related duties and formal appointment dates can differ.
Source: Mary McLeod Bethune
4. Credit practical scientific collaboration.
Only name the most famous participant.: That omits the documented role of another contributor.
Assume every agricultural product came from this program.: The evidence does not support such an unlimited claim.
Describe supported scientific, teaching, and field roles.: Role-specific descriptions explain how the work reached farming communities.
Source: George Washington Carver
5. Distinguish an initial result from a final outcome.
She secured a permanent final legal victory.: That omits the reversal.
Her challenge had an initial success followed by reversal.: This preserves the sequence and its limits.
No challenge occurred because the judgment was reversed.: A later reversal does not erase the earlier litigation.
Source: Teacher, Journalist, Activist
